• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Bob Emiliani

Leadership for the Digital Age

  • About Bob Emiliani
  • Speed Leadership
    • Overview
    • About
    • Book
    • Workshops
    • License
  • Books
  • Improvement
  • Blog
  • Contact

Student Evaluations – Part 3

July 5, 2013 by Bob Emiliani

In Part 2 of the post “Student Evaluations,” I said: “…perhaps evaluations are better directed at faculty than students, to help assure that graduates have learned the skills that, if put into practice, will help them make fewer and less significant errors.”

Teacher evaluations have a negative connotation and clearly disrespect teachers because they personalize problems. Blaming people is a stupid and ineffective solution to problems. And nobody likes to be blamed for problems. The sensible thing to do, consistent with Lean teaching, is to kaizen each course in an academic program, as described here.

This re-frames an adversarial focus on what teachers do wrong to a collegial, team-based activity focused on how teaching processes can be improved. The shift from people to process is necessary because most people would rather improve processes than be blamed for problems. This is key to overcoming stasis in higher education.

Improvement requires people’s participation, yet threatening evaluations will garner little support and immediately initiate defensive routines. Kaizen, in contrast, is non-zero-sum (win-win), by definition, for a reason: to be non-threatening in order to gain people’s participation in improvement. Kaizen allows people’s ideas, energy, and enthusiasm to flow, which helps humanize the workplace.

Faculty, staff, students, alumni, employers, and administrators participating in kaizen will do great things. It is an eye-opening experience that everyone will enjoy, especially faculty.

Filed Under: Conventional v. Lean Thinking, Lean Teaching, LeanProfessor.com

Primary Sidebar

Blog Categories

  • BobEmiliani.com
  • Continuous Improvement
  • Conventional v. Lean Thinking
  • Funny Stuff
  • Kaizen
  • Lean Leadership
  • Lean Practices
  • Lean Principles
  • Lean Teaching
  • Lean Teaching Q&A
  • Lean Tools and Methods
  • Lean University
  • LeanProfessor.com
  • Question & Answer
  • Real Lean v. Fake Lean
  • Respect for People
  • Shared Learning Resources
  • The Back Story
  • Time Machine
  • Voice of the (Student) Customer

Footer

Contact Bob

[email protected]

Providence, Rhode Island

  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Goodies

Amazon Author’s Page

YouTube Channel

Faculty Home Page

Sign Up For News

Search Footer Widget

Cubic LLC
© 2021 · Bob Emiliani · Website by Ella J Designs